Skip to content
tenantcraft
( Insights)

Your lawyer wants access to your email, not your password

When a lawyer or accountant asks for your Microsoft 365 login, they almost never need it. Your password opens far more than email, and MFA blocks it anyway. Send a copy of the mailbox, or give a separate account delegate access, and keep your own login to yourself.

Stage
Govern
Topic
Governance
Published
Written by

Tested in a live tenant,

(Short version)

Don't hand over your Microsoft 365 password. For most legal matters, send a copy of the mailbox through a link only the lawyer can open. If someone really needs live access, create a separate account with its own MFA, give it Full Access to your mailbox, and remove it when the work is done.

In this post

The email from your lawyer is short. “To review the correspondence, please send me the username and password for your business email.”

It sounds reasonable. They’re on your side, and you want this sorted. So you start typing your password into a reply.

Stop there. Your lawyer needs to read some email. Your password lets them be you, everywhere in Microsoft 365, and on most business accounts it won’t even work for them.

Why your password is the wrong answer

Your Microsoft 365 account isn’t an email account. It’s one sign-in for everything: Outlook, OneDrive, SharePoint, Teams, and whatever your business keeps in them. Hand over the password and you’ve handed over all of that, not just the folder of messages they asked about.

It also leaves you with a record that lies. Every email read, every file opened, every message deleted shows up as you. If something goes wrong later, telling your actions from theirs becomes guesswork.

And if your account has multifactor authentication (MFA) turned on, the password alone usually won’t work. In tenants created since late 2019, Microsoft turns on security defaults, which make every user register for MFA and ask for it when a sign-in needs it. An admin can turn them off, so check yours. It says MFA and blocking legacy sign-ins stop “more than 99.9%” of common identity attacks. If your account doesn’t have MFA, fix that first: a password that works on its own is the bigger problem.

I saw this from the other side. When I signed in a brand-new test account in my own tenant, Microsoft made it set up an authenticator app before it would open anything. Your lawyer would hit the same wall, and the only way past it is you approving the sign-in on your phone. At that point they’re not using your account, you are, on their behalf.

First, ask what they actually need

Most requests like this are really one of two things. Which one decides everything else.

What they need A copy of the email Live access to the mailbox
Typical reason
Review for a dispute Or a claim, audit or tax file
Ongoing work Like watching for new replies
Can it change your mail?
No It's a frozen copy
Yes Full Access can delete items
Who can do it
You, in Outlook Or your IT provider in Purview
Your IT provider In the Exchange admin center
When it ends
When they delete the file Agree that in writing
When you remove access One click, a few minutes to apply

Strong on this point A limit to plan for

Ask your lawyer a plain question: “Do you need a copy of specific emails, or do you need to watch the mailbox as new mail comes in?” For a dispute, a claim or a file review, the answer is almost always a copy.

Option 1: send a copy of the mailbox

A copy can’t be used to send email as you, can’t touch your files, and can’t delete anything in your real mailbox. That makes it the safer default.

If you do it yourself: export from Outlook

You don’t need an admin for this. Microsoft’s steps depend on which Outlook you use:

  • New Outlook for Windows: go to Settings > Files > Export, select Get started, and pick the mailbox or the specific folders you want.
  • Classic Outlook for Windows: go to File > Open & Export > Import/Export > Export to a file > Outlook Data File (.pst), then select your account. With Include subfolders ticked, Microsoft says it exports the Inbox, Calendar, Contacts and Tasks. An online archive mailbox, if you have one, isn’t part of that, so ask your IT provider about it.

Two things catch people out. First, Microsoft notes that “by default, Outlook is set to download email for the past 1 year,” and that in Cached Exchange Mode an export “will only export the items in your current cache.” If the matter goes back further, Microsoft says to turn off Cached Exchange Mode before you export, or the older mail won’t be in the file. Second, don’t save the export into a synced OneDrive folder. Microsoft says OneDrive blocks syncing .pst files.

Classic Outlook lets you put a password on the .pst file, but don’t rely on it. Microsoft says .pst passwords “aren’t intended to provide security against intentional malicious attempts to access your information.” Microsoft’s export steps for new Outlook don’t include a password at all.

The protection comes from how you send it. Upload the file to your OneDrive and share it with the lawyer’s email address only, not with “anyone with the link.” When they confirm they have it, remove the share.

If your IT provider does it: export from Microsoft Purview

For a bigger matter, or when you need to prove nothing was left out, your IT provider can search and export the mailbox in Microsoft Purview eDiscovery. Microsoft lists a few conditions:

  • Licence. The person doing the export needs a Microsoft 365 Enterprise E3 or E5 licence.
  • Time limit. Search export packages expire 14 days after they’re created, and then they’re deleted for good.
  • No guest downloads. Microsoft says “Guests can’t download exports.” Your IT provider downloads the files and sends them through your own secure channel.

If nobody at your business has an E3 or E5 licence, the Outlook export is the realistic route.

Option 2: give a separate account access to your mailbox

Sometimes a lawyer, accountant or bookkeeper genuinely needs to see new mail as it arrives. Then they get their own account, not yours.

Ask your IT provider to create a temporary account in your Microsoft 365 for that person. It gets its own password and its own MFA, so the actions Microsoft records, such as deleting or moving mail, show its name, not yours. Then they give it access to your mailbox.

Budget for one licence. For shared mailboxes, Microsoft says the person opening one “must have a licensed Exchange Online mailbox,” and that “Delegate access must be done through the delegate’s own mailbox.” Opening your mailbox works the same way, through the delegate’s own licensed mailbox, so plan for a licence on the temporary account.

In the Exchange admin center, they open Recipients > Mailboxes, select your mailbox, and open the Delegation tab. There are three permissions:

Exchange admin center > Mailboxes > Delegation

One delegate on Full Access, and nobody on Send as or Send on behalf. That combination lets someone read the mailbox but not send as the owner.

For a lawyer, the one to use is Read and manage (Full Access), and only that one. Select Edit, then Add members, pick the temporary account, select Save, and then Confirm.

Delegation > Read and manage > Add members

Adding one delegate. Pick the temporary account you made for the outside person, never a staff member's everyday account.

The Exchange admin center then said the change would appear “within 5 minutes.” The same message appeared when I removed access later.

Leave Send as and Send on behalf at zero. Microsoft says Full Access “Doesn’t allow the delegate to send messages” from the mailbox. That’s what you want for someone who only needs to read.

The catch with Full Access

Full Access is not read-only. Microsoft’s definition is that it lets the delegate “open the mailbox, and view, add and remove the contents.” A delegate can delete email, by accident or otherwise.

So give it for a defined job, write down the end date, and remove the account the day the work ends. On the same Delegation tab, select Edit, select the account, choose Delete, and confirm.

What to tell your lawyer and your IT provider

To your lawyer:

I can’t share my login, because it gives access to all of our business systems. I can send you a copy of the emails you need through a private link, or set up a separate account for you with access to my mailbox only. Which works for this matter?

To your IT provider:

Our lawyer needs to see my email for a legal matter. Please either export a copy of my mailbox for these dates, or create a temporary account with Full Access to my mailbox only, no Send as, with an end date of [date].

Most lawyers will take the copy and be glad of it. A file they control is easier to work with than someone else’s inbox.

If you already sent the password

It happens. Fix it today, not at the end of the matter.

  1. Change your password, and make it one you’ve never used anywhere else.
  2. Ask your IT provider to revoke your sessions. That’s Microsoft’s term for signing you out everywhere. Microsoft notes that access tokens last 1 hour by default, so a device already signed in can keep working for up to an hour after.
  3. Check your sign-in methods. Make sure no new phone or authenticator app was added to your account.
  4. Check for email forwarding and rules. In the Exchange admin center, your mailbox has an Email forwarding setting. Also check your Outlook inbox rules for anything that forwards, redirects or deletes mail, because those don’t show up in that setting.

What this does not fix

  • It doesn’t make the lawyer’s copy secure. Once they have the .pst file, it lives on their systems. Agree in writing how long they keep it and how they delete it.
  • It doesn’t cover your files. A mailbox export or mailbox delegation covers email only. If they need OneDrive or SharePoint files, share those folders separately, read-only.
  • It doesn’t replace a records policy. If legal requests are regular for your business, talk to your IT provider about holds and retention, so nothing gets deleted while a matter is open.

The bottom line

Your lawyer wants your email, not your identity. Send a copy through a private link for almost every legal matter. If they truly need live access, give a separate account Full Access to your mailbox only, with an end date, and never share the password that runs your whole business.

(Paired checklist, 7 pages)

Permissions Cleanup & Governance Prep Checklist

You get one email with the link. That's the only email.

Read it on the site
  • Audit broken inheritance, scope sprawl, oversharing, and orphaned accounts
  • The limits that decide what migrates clean: 5,000 / 50,000 scopes, 100,000 items
  • Prepare identity so permissions survive the move to Microsoft Entra ID
  • Design and remediate a clean, group-based model before cutover
Sneak peek

Document preview

100%

Loading the document…